Browse: Home / Cancer / Soy might not be protecting women from breast cancer

Menu

Skip to content
  • About
  • Better Body Chemistry School
  • Book a health conversation
  • Speaking query
  • The “Big” Spoons
Header image

BBC

Small things can make a big difference to your health

advertisement

Menu

Skip to content
  • Home
  • Free Resources
    • 31 days to Better Body Chemistry
    • Willpower Report
    • Weight loss e-course
    • The ups and downs of insulin resistance
    • Candy Floss Boards
    • Weight tracker
  • Library
  • Shop
  • Baobab Adventures
  • Lucky dip
  • Buy me a coffee
  • Video gallery
  • Contact

Soy might not be protecting women from breast cancer

Posted by Dr Sandy on in Cancer | 319 Views | Leave a response
phytoestrogen watering breast cancer

Tumour talk turns nasty in breast cancer cells, when women with breast cancer, sip on soy shakes.

Population studies suggest soy supplementation can protect women against breast cancer, but do they ?

Soy as a health food

Soy’s big claim to fame, is it has isoflavones. These isoflavones are classed as anti-oxidants. And since too much oxidation is BAD, anti-oxidants are assumed to always be GOOD.

But, isoflavones are more than just anti-oxidants, they structurally look a lot like estrogen, so in addition to being classed as anti-oxidants, they are also phytoestrogens (plant estrogens). This special property, is the reason they are touted as remedy for the “troubles” associated with menopause and beyond. Hormonally speaking, menopause is characterized by a loss of estrogen.

Munching on soy protein, has the potential to put back the estrogen, making everything better.

But, what happens when there is too much estrogen ?

Breast cancer.

Estrogen makes cells divide

Many, not all, breast cancers are estrogen positive.

And this means, they are motivated to grow, lots, in the presence of estrogen.

And soy…………………. is an estrogen.

Eish !

Comparing apples and apples

But, populations that traditionally eat lots of “fermented” soy products – don’t have high rates of breast cancer.

So what is the story ?

The soy story

A team of researchers from New York’s at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Centre, set about trying to figure it out. The team decided to look at what happens in women with a diagnosis of breast cancer.

The ladies had all received the devastating news and were in limbo, waiting for surgery to remove the tumour. The ladies were divided into two groups. Both groups of ladies were given a “prescription” for a protein shake. Half of the ladies in this awful predicament, were put onto a soy based protein shake, the other half, were put on a milk based product.

The ladies were told to consume the shakes, twice a day, up until the day before the surgery. On average, the ladies waited 14-15 days, for their surgery to take place.

Breast cancer talk

A biopsy of the tumour was taken for each lady, at the start of the study and then, when the tumour was removed, during the surgery, a bit was kept for analysis. The team used cutting edge technology, to establish which genes were turned on/off, in the two tumour specimens.

They found the tumour talk changed in the group of ladies consuming the soy shakes.

And the change was “disturbing” and correlated with the levels of genistein in their blood samples. (Genistein is one of the soy isoflavones).

An UPSET tumour

A whole bunch of genes, 21 in total, changed their expression levels. Several gene expression changes caught the eye of the team. The most troubling, a group of genes, associated with cell proliferation, were all firing louder, this included the FGFR2 gene, as well as E2F5, BUB1, CCNB2, MYBL2, CDK1, and CDC20.

I know this just looks like gobbledee goo, so let me try put it in perspective. The FGFR2 gene is officially considered to be a cancer causing gene i.e. a oncogene and when it is expressed in a tumour, it usually means, things will not end well.

So……………..

Soy trips the switch

Potentially making things worse, not better.

Based on this study, which is in humans with cancer, it seems taking in extra soy, is NOT a health move. In fact, it may be detrimental. Since, the evidence that soy supplementation protects bones, is at best sketchy – supplementing with soy is probably not a good idea.


The Effects of Soy Supplementation on Gene Expression in Breast Cancer: A Randomized Placebo-Controlled Study. JNCI Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 2014; 106 (9): dju189 M. Shike, A. S. Doane, L. Russo, R. Cabal, J. Reis-Filo, W. Gerald, H. Cody, R. Khanin, J. Bromberg, L. Norton.

Further reading

phytoestrogens taking out spermSoy foods shooting down the little guys

We’ve been programmed to believe soy is a health food, but as far sperm are concerned, the lady of the soy bean wreaks havoc on sperm counts.

estrogen being ordered out during a hysterectomyIf you want to stop brain rust – install a red robot

Iron accumulates inside the human body, especially the brain.  Iron and oxygen don’t mix……. the combination leads to rusty parts and serious breakdowns.

starving cancer

You can stop cancer cells growing by cutting off their food supply

For a cancer cell to grow big and strong,  it needs to eat. So one way to weaken them, is to put them on a serious diet.

Want better body chemisty ? 

Subscribe to E-spoons, to get e-mail updates with  tips & strategies that will help you experience BETTER BODY CHEMISTRY and better health.

View previous E-spoons.

Close

NOTE : Privacy & spam policy. Spoonful of Science will not rent, trade or sell the e-mail list to anyone. You can unsubscribe at any time by following the unsubscribe link.

Posted in Cancer | Tagged breast canceer, estrogen, isoflavones, protein shakes, soy, tumour

Connect with us

facebook you tube pinterest 40 Linkedin

Instagram

betterbodychemistry
@betterbodychemistry
Follow
A health “nut” (classified as a lean mass hyper-responder) dropped his cholesterol by adding 12 Oreos a day to his keto diet.

Sounds delicious, right? 

But if you’re insulin resistant, this cookie hack could backfire.

🍪 Curious about how it actually worked? I break it down in this short.

And if you want more quirky science stories that help you understand your metabolism — 💌 I send them out via email. Link in bio to join.

#oreoexperiment #insulinresistance #cholesterolfix #ldlcholesterol #lowcarblife #metabolicsyndrome #healthcurious #betterbodychemistry 
#LMHR #leanmusclehyperresponder
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
A health “nut” (classified as a lean mass hyper-responder) dropped his cholesterol by adding 12 Oreos a day to his keto diet. Sounds delicious, right? But if you’re insulin resistant, this cookie hack could backfire. 🍪 Curious about how it actually worked? I break it down in this short. And if you want more quirky science stories that help you understand your metabolism — 💌 I send them out via email. Link in bio to join. #oreoexperiment #insulinresistance #cholesterolfix #ldlcholesterol #lowcarblife #metabolicsyndrome #healthcurious #betterbodychemistry #LMHR #leanmusclehyperresponder
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
1/9
Ever wonder why your LDL spikes on keto?

It’s not the bacon. 🥓
It’s your liver — working overtime to fuel your body.

On keto, your cells switch from burning sugar to burning fat.
Your liver responds by sending out VLDL particles — packed with fat.
Once the fat is dropped off, what’s left becomes LDL.

⚠️ And that’s what shows up on blood work.
😱 Cue panic.

But if your liver is healthy, those LDLs are just passing through.
If not? They hang around. That’s when trouble starts.

🎥 Watch to understand the science behind rising LDL on keto — and why context matters.

#KetoScience #LMHR #LeanMassHyperResponder #LDLcholesterol #LowCarbLife #BetterBodyChemistry #MetabolicHealth #RootCause
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Ever wonder why your LDL spikes on keto? It’s not the bacon. 🥓 It’s your liver — working overtime to fuel your body. On keto, your cells switch from burning sugar to burning fat. Your liver responds by sending out VLDL particles — packed with fat. Once the fat is dropped off, what’s left becomes LDL. ⚠️ And that’s what shows up on blood work. 😱 Cue panic. But if your liver is healthy, those LDLs are just passing through. If not? They hang around. That’s when trouble starts. 🎥 Watch to understand the science behind rising LDL on keto — and why context matters. #KetoScience #LMHR #LeanMassHyperResponder #LDLcholesterol #LowCarbLife #BetterBodyChemistry #MetabolicHealth #RootCause
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
2/9
Is your LDL sky-high… but everything else looks great?

If you’re lean, athletic, and insulin sensitive — you might be what researchers are calling a Lean Mass Hyper-Responder (LMHR).

In this reel, I unpack new research comparing LMHRs to everyday folks. The LDL in LMHRs is often >190 mg/dL — a number that would alarm most doctors — but their CAC scores suggest their hearts are doing just fine.

The takeaway?
LDL might be loud, but it’s not always telling the truth.
The full picture matters.

🎬 This is Part 2 in my LMHR cholesterol series. Follow so you don’t miss Part 3, where we dive into the Lipid Energy Model — a theory that may explain what’s going on in LMHRs (and maybe in you too)

#LDL #Cholesterol #LMHR #InsulinResistance #CACscore #HeartHealth #LipidEnergyModel #BetterBodyChemistry #MetabolicHealth #TyGIndex #HealthEducation #LowCarbScience
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Is your LDL sky-high… but everything else looks great? If you’re lean, athletic, and insulin sensitive — you might be what researchers are calling a Lean Mass Hyper-Responder (LMHR). In this reel, I unpack new research comparing LMHRs to everyday folks. The LDL in LMHRs is often >190 mg/dL — a number that would alarm most doctors — but their CAC scores suggest their hearts are doing just fine. The takeaway? LDL might be loud, but it’s not always telling the truth. The full picture matters. 🎬 This is Part 2 in my LMHR cholesterol series. Follow so you don’t miss Part 3, where we dive into the Lipid Energy Model — a theory that may explain what’s going on in LMHRs (and maybe in you too) #LDL #Cholesterol #LMHR #InsulinResistance #CACscore #HeartHealth #LipidEnergyModel #BetterBodyChemistry #MetabolicHealth #TyGIndex #HealthEducation #LowCarbScience
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
3/9
Your numbers say danger zone — but your body says everything’s fine.
You might be an LMHR.

🎥 This is part 1 of a bigger story. Follow for what happens next.

#LDL #Cholesterol #LowCarbLife #MetabolicHealth #InsulinResistance 
#HeartHealth #KetoProblems #HealthExplained #BodyChemistry #BetterBodyChemistry 
#HealthTips #WellnessJourney #Biohacking #FunctionalMedicine #KnowYourNumbers
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Your numbers say danger zone — but your body says everything’s fine. You might be an LMHR. 🎥 This is part 1 of a bigger story. Follow for what happens next. #LDL #Cholesterol #LowCarbLife #MetabolicHealth #InsulinResistance #HeartHealth #KetoProblems #HealthExplained #BodyChemistry #BetterBodyChemistry #HealthTips #WellnessJourney #Biohacking #FunctionalMedicine #KnowYourNumbers
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
4/9
🎯 One number.

One test you’ve probably never had… even though the data is already in your blood work.

It’s called the TyG Index—and it’s one of the best ways to see if insulin resistance is quietly messing with your metabolism.

🔍 My Metabolic Check makes it easy to calculate, understand, and use this number—and right now, you can get it FREE inside the Next Level Life Bundle.

💡You don’t need to figure everything out today.
But you do need to grab access before the bundle closes.

🕛 Deadline: Tonight at midnight (March 27)
🎁 100+ personal development tools
💻 Yours forever—if you sign up in time.

🔗 Link in bio

#NextLevelLifeBundle #MetabolicCheck #TyGIndex #InsulinResistance #MetabolicHealth #BloodSugarBalance #FreeHealthTools #HealthResources #ScienceBasedHealth #KnowYourNumbers #SugarCrashFix #EnergySupport #FreebieAlert #BetterBodyChemistry #DeadlineAlert
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
🎯 One number. One test you’ve probably never had… even though the data is already in your blood work. It’s called the TyG Index—and it’s one of the best ways to see if insulin resistance is quietly messing with your metabolism. 🔍 My Metabolic Check makes it easy to calculate, understand, and use this number—and right now, you can get it FREE inside the Next Level Life Bundle. 💡You don’t need to figure everything out today. But you do need to grab access before the bundle closes. 🕛 Deadline: Tonight at midnight (March 27) 🎁 100+ personal development tools 💻 Yours forever—if you sign up in time. 🔗 Link in bio #NextLevelLifeBundle #MetabolicCheck #TyGIndex #InsulinResistance #MetabolicHealth #BloodSugarBalance #FreeHealthTools #HealthResources #ScienceBasedHealth #KnowYourNumbers #SugarCrashFix #EnergySupport #FreebieAlert #BetterBodyChemistry #DeadlineAlert
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
5/9
It’s not Tai Chi... 🥋
It’s the TyG Index that brings balance to your metabolism.

🐾 If you’re wondering whether insulin resistance might be behind your sugar crashes, stubborn weight, or low energy—there’s a number that can help.

🧪 It’s based on ordinary blood work.
📊 It’s called the TyG Index.
💻 And you can calculate it yourself using my Metabolic Check tool—available now for FREE in the Next Level Life Bundle.

But hurry...
⏳ The bundle closes tomorrow at midnight (March 27)!
🔗 Link in bio

#TyGIndex #MetabolicCheck #InsulinResistance #NextLevelLifeBundle #BloodSugarBalance #FreeHealthTool #MetabolicHealth #KnowYourNumbers #BetterBodyChemistry #ScienceBasedHealth #EnergyFix #HealthTools #BundleCountdown
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
It’s not Tai Chi... 🥋 It’s the TyG Index that brings balance to your metabolism. 🐾 If you’re wondering whether insulin resistance might be behind your sugar crashes, stubborn weight, or low energy—there’s a number that can help. 🧪 It’s based on ordinary blood work. 📊 It’s called the TyG Index. 💻 And you can calculate it yourself using my Metabolic Check tool—available now for FREE in the Next Level Life Bundle. But hurry... ⏳ The bundle closes tomorrow at midnight (March 27)! 🔗 Link in bio #TyGIndex #MetabolicCheck #InsulinResistance #NextLevelLifeBundle #BloodSugarBalance #FreeHealthTool #MetabolicHealth #KnowYourNumbers #BetterBodyChemistry #ScienceBasedHealth #EnergyFix #HealthTools #BundleCountdown
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
6/9
🩸 Did your metabolism ace the test?

There’s a surprising number hiding in your standard blood work…

It’s called the TyG Index, and it could be your first clue that insulin resistance is quietly messing with your energy, weight, or sugar levels.

🎯 Want to know your number?

Metabolic Check is my contribution to the [Next Level Life Bundle]—and right now, you can grab it for FREE (along with 100+ other personal growth resources).

But don’t wait—
🕛 Bundle closes Thursday at midnight (March 27).
🔗 Link in bio!
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
🩸 Did your metabolism ace the test? There’s a surprising number hiding in your standard blood work… It’s called the TyG Index, and it could be your first clue that insulin resistance is quietly messing with your energy, weight, or sugar levels. 🎯 Want to know your number? Metabolic Check is my contribution to the [Next Level Life Bundle]—and right now, you can grab it for FREE (along with 100+ other personal growth resources). But don’t wait— 🕛 Bundle closes Thursday at midnight (March 27). 🔗 Link in bio!
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
7/9
🚨 It’s LIVE!
The Next Level Life Bundle just dropped—and it’s bursting with 100+ free resources to help you feel better, think clearer, and actually make progress on the things that matter.

🧠 My contribution?
Metabolic Check
A quick, science-backed tool to help you figure out if insulin resistance might be messing with your energy, weight, or sugar levels.
No fluff. No guessing. Just numbers you can use.

✨ And that’s just ONE of the incredible resources inside.
The bundle is only available until March 27—and yes, it’s completely free.

📥 Grab your copy now — link in bio.

#NextLevelLifeBundle #MetabolicCheck #InsulinResistance #BloodSugarBalance #FreebieAlert #BetterBodyChemistry #FreeResources #HealthGoals #ScienceBased #BundleLaunch #WomenInScience #MindBodyHealth #EnergySupport #Type2Diabetes #MetabolicHealth
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
🚨 It’s LIVE! The Next Level Life Bundle just dropped—and it’s bursting with 100+ free resources to help you feel better, think clearer, and actually make progress on the things that matter. 🧠 My contribution? Metabolic Check A quick, science-backed tool to help you figure out if insulin resistance might be messing with your energy, weight, or sugar levels. No fluff. No guessing. Just numbers you can use. ✨ And that’s just ONE of the incredible resources inside. The bundle is only available until March 27—and yes, it’s completely free. 📥 Grab your copy now — link in bio. #NextLevelLifeBundle #MetabolicCheck #InsulinResistance #BloodSugarBalance #FreebieAlert #BetterBodyChemistry #FreeResources #HealthGoals #ScienceBased #BundleLaunch #WomenInScience #MindBodyHealth #EnergySupport #Type2Diabetes #MetabolicHealth
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
8/9
🧪 Insulin resistance is behind rising rates of heart disease, diabetes, and stubborn weight gain… but most people have no idea they have it.

Why? Because no one’s measuring it.
But it can be measured—if you know how.

📊 That’s exactly what you’ll learn in Metabolic Check, my contribution to the Next Level Life Bundle.
It helps you uncover hidden risks using the blood work you already have.

💥 The bundle goes live soon—with tons of resources to help you smash your goals and take control of your health.

🎁 And yes, it's completely FREE (for a few days only).

🔗 Get on the waitlist—link in bio!

#NextLevelLifeBundle #MetabolicCheck #InsulinResistance #KnowYourNumbers #BetterBodyChemistry #HeartHealth #MetabolicHealth #HealthTools #ScienceBased #BloodSugarBalance #FreeBundle #YouCanMeasureIt
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
🧪 Insulin resistance is behind rising rates of heart disease, diabetes, and stubborn weight gain… but most people have no idea they have it. Why? Because no one’s measuring it. But it can be measured—if you know how. 📊 That’s exactly what you’ll learn in Metabolic Check, my contribution to the Next Level Life Bundle. It helps you uncover hidden risks using the blood work you already have. 💥 The bundle goes live soon—with tons of resources to help you smash your goals and take control of your health. 🎁 And yes, it's completely FREE (for a few days only). 🔗 Get on the waitlist—link in bio! #NextLevelLifeBundle #MetabolicCheck #InsulinResistance #KnowYourNumbers #BetterBodyChemistry #HeartHealth #MetabolicHealth #HealthTools #ScienceBased #BloodSugarBalance #FreeBundle #YouCanMeasureIt
1 month ago
View on Instagram |
9/9
View on Instagram

FEELING….

sign posts then you need better body chemistry.

Grab our free E-course

“31 days to better body chemistry”

The advice is simple to follow and based on REAL science, not hype

Need more information ? Click here

  • Popular
  • Featured
  • Recent
  • asprosin the sugar plum fairy

    Why sugar levels are high despite NOT eating

    22915 views / Posted
  • oatmeal breakfast being beaten by egg

    Which is a better breakfast, egg or oatmeal ?

    22701 views / Posted
  • poop getting stuck

    The fix for constipation is to go on a low fibre diet

    22256 views / Posted
  • chewing gum relieving postoperative ileus

    A stick of chewing gum gets the gut going after surgery

    16974 views / Posted
  • carbonated water bubbles fill you up

    Fizzing up the water flattens your appetite

    15847 views / Posted
  • sun extracting cholesterol

    Make sure you have your “annual” check-up in the summer time

    / Dr Sandy
  • sending your kid to bootcamp won't stop childhood obesity

    Moving more won’t stop your kid from getting fat

    / Dr Sandy
  • cholesterol at the scene of the accident

    Bone cells are stiffening up your arteries not cholesterol

    / Dr Sandy
  • brain size the problem in ADHD

    Are kids with ADHD just acting according to their brain age

    / Dr Sandy
  • plastering the blood vessel with calcium

    Calcium supplements are building bones and breaking hearts

    / Dr Sandy
  • Plant baring hamburgers

    Does Soy Build Muscle? Exploring the Science Behind Protein Choices

    / Dr Sandy
  • img-40

    The Dark Side of Weight Loss Drugs

    / Dr Sandy
  • Mother Nature stealing from peter to pay paul

    Are You Losing Muscle Without Realizing It? Here’s How to Protect It

    / Dr Sandy
  • img-42

    Your Resting Heart Rate could be a Red Flag for Metabolic Trouble

    / Dr Sandy
  • baby muscle mesmerized by the TV

    Tots watching too much TV end up being muscle flops

    / Dr Sandy

RSS Recent posts

Dr Sandy Dr Sandy Evans, PhD

Located in Johannesburg, South Africa

Disclaimer : The stories and articles are provided as a service. Dr Sandy's opinions are for information only, and are not intended to diagnose or prescribe. For your specific diagnosis and treatment, consult your doctor or health care provider.
 

Book an appointment

Calendar icon
 

Connect with Dr Sandy

facebook 40
you tube 40
pinterest 40
linkedin 40
 

Categories

Featured posts

  • asprosin the sugar plum fairy

    Why sugar levels are high despite NOT eating

    22915 views / Posted
  • oatmeal breakfast being beaten by egg

    Which is a better breakfast, egg or oatmeal ?

    22701 views / Posted
  • poop getting stuck

    The fix for constipation is to go on a low fibre diet

    22256 views / Posted
 

©2011-2025 Spoonful of Science

Menu

  • Meet Dr Sandy
  • Disclosure/disclaimer
  • Privacy policy
  • Comment policy
  • Contact