Browse: Home / dieting / The semantics of dieting can easily lead to dieting faux pas

Menu

Skip to content
  • About
  • Better Body Chemistry School
  • Book a health conversation
  • Speaking query
  • The “Big” Spoons
Header image

BBC

Small things can make a big difference to your health

advertisement

Menu

Skip to content
  • Home
  • Free Resources
    • 31 days to Better Body Chemistry
    • Willpower Report
    • Weight loss e-course
    • Better Body Chemistry for Expecting Moms
    • The ups and downs of insulin resistance
    • Candy Floss Boards
    • Weight tracker
    • Sound bites
  • Library
  • Shop
  • Lucky dip
  • Buy me a coffee
  • Video gallery
  • Contact

The semantics of dieting can easily lead to dieting faux pas

Posted by Dr Sandy on in dieting | 494 Views | Leave a response
Tweet
Share
Pin
Share

Click to listen to the audio…

How dieting terminology can lead to “dieting” mistakes

pasta wearing a disguise

You’re currently “ON DIET”, to be safe, you order a salad, but you may not be acting as virtuously as you think because a salad is not always a salad.

You sit down to order at a cafe.  You’re currently “ON DIET”, your status necessitates that you choose very wisely.  To be safe you turn to the section labelled salads.  Glance through the options and make your choice.

STOP.

You may not be acting as virtuously as you think.

When a salad is not a salad

Traditionally the term salad, referred to a collection of vegetables and herbs, that had been cut up and seasoned,  and were served raw.  greens

These days, restaurant salads can include a variety of less traditional ingredients including :

  • Pasta
  • Meat
  • Cheese
  • Bread

That “pasta salad” would sit quite comfortably in the Pasta Section of the menu.  But in the pasta section, you would have given it a miss.  The restaurateur knew this, so he added a lettuce leaf,  jacked up the price and stuck the dish in the salad section.

Dieters being duped

Research reported in the Journal of Consumer Research, found that dieters  were  frequently conned by terminology.

 The team were able to demonstrate the phenomenon in a group of downtown “shoppers”.

 They stopped 77  shoppers and asked to do a THOUGHT EXPERIMENT.  They imagined that they were at their favourite restaurant, which was offering A SPECIAL,  on a pasta-cum-salad meal.  The ingredients included diced tomatoes, onions and red peppers tossed with pasta shells, salami, mozzarella cheese and dressed with a savoury herb vinaigrette.  Served chilled on a bed of fresh romaine lettuce.

In the thought experiment, the  dish was served either as  “a salad” or “a pasta”.

The shoppers were asked to rate how healthy the meal was and then, they completed a little survey, to establish if they were currently ON DIET.

The response varied according to the person’s dieting status.

graph comparing responses of dieters and non-dieters to the pasta-cum-salad

Graph comparing responses of dieters and non-dieters to the pasta-cum-salad.© 2011 by JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH,Inc.

The dieters perceived the meal to be less healthy, when it was called “a pasta”.  Those individuals not dieting,  were unconcerned about the health connotations of the meal and failed to make the “healthful” link.

So what……….this is a thought experiment.  No food was actually consumed – surely dieters would not make the mistake of eating more.   Well… not really.

Dieters don’t always think

Our team moved from the streets to the lab, to test what would ACTUALLY happen, in a real life scenario. Since they weren’t rich enough to provide 100s of meals, they did part 2, on college students, feeding them chews and paying them with course credits.

the chews options

The chews were either marketed as candy or fruit chews.

To reinforce the point, the students were privy to the ingredient list and the researchers made sure, they actually read the ingredient list, by quizzing them afterwards.  Those who failed the test, were removed from the study.

Exactly the same thing happened…………

healthfuless of chews

Graph showing the perceived healthfulness of chews for dieters and non-dieters. © 2011 by JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH,Inc.

Dieters put the fruit chews on a pedestal, or maybe it would be more accurate to say, they “trashed” the candy chews.
Amount of chews eaten

Graph showing the amount of chews eaten by students. © 2011 by JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH,Inc.

And them, they ate more of them, when they were given an opportunity to snack on them.

Eish !  Talk about a diet faux pas.

Could this be happening to you ?

Dieter beware of conditioning

The team tried to unpack, why dieters, who on paper at least, should be more attuned to healthy foods,  were so easily dubed.

They suspect the diet fail, happened  because of conditioning.

Dieting is HARD WORK

You have to think about  what to eat, when and how much.  And to make matters worse, when you’re DIETING, being a little hungry goes with the territory.

Our team speculated that dieters brains are looking for short cuts………….

good versus bad food with eyes watching

Years and years of marketing, have led to foods being classified as  “good” or  “bad”.  When a dieter encounters a so called “good” food, they let their guard down.

And since they’re typically a little hungry, it’s easy to overdo it.

In contrast to the dieter, the   non-dieter is motivated by  one thing –  is what is on offer, “good to eat”.   If it is, they will tuck in, until THEY’VE HAD ENOUGH.

Since they’re not chronically deprived, ENOUGH is reached sooner.

Now for the bad news…………….the food industry  is out to sabotage your diet.

Exploiting the dieters’ fixation

Okay, that might be a bit over the top, but the food industry is in business to make profits.

They only make profit when you buy.

The food industry is aware that food terms can become tainted in the dieters head.  They know the dieter is on the lookout for specific terms, so they change the terms.  By modifying the offensive term, the food item moves from the “bad” category to the “good”.

Katching, katching – money in the cash register.

And an extra layer of fat on your hips !

It is all in the name

food industry executive naming the foodsSome “other” products  masquerading as “healthful”, when their true healthfulness is subject to debate, include :

  • Potato chips are “veggie chips”
  • Milkshakes are “smoothies’
  • Sugary drinks are “flavoured water”
  • The word “organic” elevates foods to healthful in a flash.   Organic cookies are still full of sugar !

Study the list of ingredients

So if you’re ON DIET and considering popping something into your mouth.  STOP.  Don’t assume anything – read the list of ingredients, then decide whether to tuck in or skip out.

The Impact of Product Name on Dieters’ and Non-Dieters’ Food Evaluations and Consumption. Journal of Consumer Research (2011)  38(4): 390-405.  Caglar Irmak, Beth Vallen, and Stefanie Rosen Robinson.

Further reading

scientist grinding up mouse food

Smoothies, whether they’re low carb or high carb, can make you fat

If you’re weight watching, the question to ask about a food, is not, what is the carb count, but what is it’s texture. Soft foods, aka processed foods, are driving obesity.

fat sipply cup filled with fruit juice

Juicing up is fattening up

If you crunch the numbers – a glass of apple juice can actually have a few more calories than a glass of cola. And those calories are not equal.

fake food the problem

Fake food – it’s killing us softly, with eat bite

Modern food processing techniques mean we’re increasingly eating fake food. The extra and missing ingredients in our diet are making us fat and sick.

 

This is one of the 31 tips & strategies, in our free, zero-to-one weight loss course, for more tips & strategies enrol NOW….
enrol is zero to one course

Tweet
Share
Pin
Share
Posted in dieting | Tagged dieting, fat, food industry, list of ingredients, milkshakes, organic, potatoe chips, salad, smoothies, sugary drinks

Sugar gremlins are REAL

Connect with us

facebook you tube pinterest 40 Linkedin

Instagram

betterbodychemistry
@betterbodychemistry
Follow
Imagine a world where you enjoy nature on your terms and reduce stress levels at the same time. Our research shows that as little as 10 minutes in nature can bring about a remarkable drop in cortisol. Take control of your body chemistry and unleash your inner stress warrior. 

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/nmNGZnd0T #BalanceYourCortisol #BetterBodyChemistry #HealthyLiving #ManageStress #QuantifyStressRelief #GoGreen #TransformWithNature #BreakFreeFromStress #SelfCare #PracticalStressSolutions #StressRelief #HealingPowerOfNature
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Imagine a world where you enjoy nature on your terms and reduce stress levels at the same time. Our research shows that as little as 10 minutes in nature can bring about a remarkable drop in cortisol. Take control of your body chemistry and unleash your inner stress warrior. Click for more https://bsapp.ai/nmNGZnd0T #BalanceYourCortisol #BetterBodyChemistry #HealthyLiving #ManageStress #QuantifyStressRelief #GoGreen #TransformWithNature #BreakFreeFromStress #SelfCare #PracticalStressSolutions #StressRelief #HealingPowerOfNature
12 hours ago
View on Instagram |
1/9
No more dreading the gym! Discover the secret to transforming your exercise routine from a painful experience to a pleasurable one. Get ready to fall in love with fitness! 🏆

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/gDYoXPtMX #HealthyHabits #HealthyLifestyle #PositiveProgression #ExerciseMotivation #BetterBodyChemistry #FitnessVictories #ExerciseHacks #ExerciseTips #FitnessForAll #MindBodyConnection #LoveYourWorkout
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
No more dreading the gym! Discover the secret to transforming your exercise routine from a painful experience to a pleasurable one. Get ready to fall in love with fitness! 🏆 Click for more https://bsapp.ai/gDYoXPtMX #HealthyHabits #HealthyLifestyle #PositiveProgression #ExerciseMotivation #BetterBodyChemistry #FitnessVictories #ExerciseHacks #ExerciseTips #FitnessForAll #MindBodyConnection #LoveYourWorkout
20 hours ago
View on Instagram |
2/9
Attention health-conscious warriors! It's time to unravel a hidden aspect of soy-based meat substitutes that might impact your well-being. While these products offer a plant-powered alternative to traditional meat, it's crucial to address the potential hormonal implications. Soy contains compounds called phytoestrogens, which mimic the effects of estrogen in the body. This means that consuming soy-based meat substitutes,  could potentially disrupt hormonal balance, particularly in men.

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/P_Qtv7VEa #FoodAwareness #HormoneHealth #HealthEducation #EstrogenicActivity #MeatSubstitutes #TofuBurger #BetterBodyChemistry #HormoneBalance #HormonesInFood #HealthConcerns #SyntheticHormones
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Attention health-conscious warriors! It's time to unravel a hidden aspect of soy-based meat substitutes that might impact your well-being. While these products offer a plant-powered alternative to traditional meat, it's crucial to address the potential hormonal implications. Soy contains compounds called phytoestrogens, which mimic the effects of estrogen in the body. This means that consuming soy-based meat substitutes, could potentially disrupt hormonal balance, particularly in men. Click for more https://bsapp.ai/P_Qtv7VEa #FoodAwareness #HormoneHealth #HealthEducation #EstrogenicActivity #MeatSubstitutes #TofuBurger #BetterBodyChemistry #HormoneBalance #HormonesInFood #HealthConcerns #SyntheticHormones
1 day ago
View on Instagram |
3/9
Did you know that exercising before a meal can help control your sugar levels? BETTER BODY CHEMISTRY TV can teach you how to incorporate this into your daily routine.

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/b4OljcAHu #metabolism #insulinresistance #healthyeating #exercisesnacking #smallchangesbigresults #glucosecontrol #healthylifestyle #sugarcontrol #betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Did you know that exercising before a meal can help control your sugar levels? BETTER BODY CHEMISTRY TV can teach you how to incorporate this into your daily routine. Click for more https://bsapp.ai/b4OljcAHu #metabolism #insulinresistance #healthyeating #exercisesnacking #smallchangesbigresults #glucosecontrol #healthylifestyle #sugarcontrol #betterbodychemistry
2 days ago
View on Instagram |
4/9
Ready to make a change? Discover the incredible benefits of leg fidgeting and how it can empower you to take control of your heart health and life. 

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/vk8oySki1 #SedentaryLifestyle #FidgetingForHealth #PreventHeartDisease #HeartWellness #HeartHealth #HealthyHabits #LegPower #EndothelialFunction #HealthyLiving #AtherosclerosisPrevention #BetterBodyChemistry #HeartProtection
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Ready to make a change? Discover the incredible benefits of leg fidgeting and how it can empower you to take control of your heart health and life. Click for more https://bsapp.ai/vk8oySki1 #SedentaryLifestyle #FidgetingForHealth #PreventHeartDisease #HeartWellness #HeartHealth #HealthyHabits #LegPower #EndothelialFunction #HealthyLiving #AtherosclerosisPrevention #BetterBodyChemistry #HeartProtection
2 days ago
View on Instagram |
5/9
🌱🍬 Sweetness meets greens in the ultimate flavor makeover! Discover the Coffee Principle and turn your veggies into culinary masterpieces!

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/Y9w5eXntH #BetterBodyChemistry #ParentingTips #TasteTransformation #GreensForLife #FamilyHealth #HealthyHacks #GreenVegetables #PickyEaters #HealthyLiving #TastyGreens #HappyHealthyKids #NutritionHacks
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
🌱🍬 Sweetness meets greens in the ultimate flavor makeover! Discover the Coffee Principle and turn your veggies into culinary masterpieces! Click for more https://bsapp.ai/Y9w5eXntH #BetterBodyChemistry #ParentingTips #TasteTransformation #GreensForLife #FamilyHealth #HealthyHacks #GreenVegetables #PickyEaters #HealthyLiving #TastyGreens #HappyHealthyKids #NutritionHacks
3 days ago
View on Instagram |
6/9
Don't let poor indoor air quality take a toll on your health. Discover how adding a few houseplants to your home or office can help filter out toxins and improve air quality.

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/J9OBpyx_S #BetterBodyChemistry #NaturalSolutions #HealthTips #CarbonDioxide #BreatheBetter #PollutionSolutions #AirFilters #HealthyLiving
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Don't let poor indoor air quality take a toll on your health. Discover how adding a few houseplants to your home or office can help filter out toxins and improve air quality. Click for more https://bsapp.ai/J9OBpyx_S #BetterBodyChemistry #NaturalSolutions #HealthTips #CarbonDioxide #BreatheBetter #PollutionSolutions #AirFilters #HealthyLiving
4 days ago
View on Instagram |
7/9
Are you avoiding the sun? It might be doing more harm than good. New research shows that sun avoiding is linked to an increased risk of dying early.

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/KpyQ1OMJz #healthylifestyle #healthtips #healthyliving #cardiovasculardisease #sunsafety #healthyhabits #longevity #sunworshipper #betterbodychemistry #cancerprevention #skinhealth
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Are you avoiding the sun? It might be doing more harm than good. New research shows that sun avoiding is linked to an increased risk of dying early. Click for more https://bsapp.ai/KpyQ1OMJz #healthylifestyle #healthtips #healthyliving #cardiovasculardisease #sunsafety #healthyhabits #longevity #sunworshipper #betterbodychemistry #cancerprevention #skinhealth
4 days ago
View on Instagram |
8/9
Say goodbye to underarm odor and hello to better body chemistry! Discover how to choose the right underarm cosmetic and protect yourself from the potential risk of breast cancer. 

Click for more https://bsapp.ai/hJwA-cTl4 #betterbodychemistry #StaySafe #HealthyChoices #BreastCancerAwareness #antiperspirants #deodorants #aluminiumandhealth #healthylifestyle #HealthyHabits #breastcancerprevention
betterbodychemistry
betterbodychemistry
•
Follow
Say goodbye to underarm odor and hello to better body chemistry! Discover how to choose the right underarm cosmetic and protect yourself from the potential risk of breast cancer. Click for more https://bsapp.ai/hJwA-cTl4 #betterbodychemistry #StaySafe #HealthyChoices #BreastCancerAwareness #antiperspirants #deodorants #aluminiumandhealth #healthylifestyle #HealthyHabits #breastcancerprevention
5 days ago
View on Instagram |
9/9
View on Instagram
willpower report
  • Popular
  • Featured
  • Recent
  • asprosin the sugar plum fairy

    Why sugar levels are high despite NOT eating

    22149 views / Posted
  • poop getting stuck

    The fix for constipation is to go on a low fibre diet

    21278 views / Posted
  • oatmeal breakfast being beaten by egg

    Which is a better breakfast, egg or oatmeal ?

    19778 views / Posted
  • chewing gum relieving postoperative ileus

    A stick of chewing gum gets the gut going after surgery

    16836 views / Posted
  • carbonated water bubbles fill you up

    Fizzing up the water flattens your appetite

    15733 views / Posted
  • sun extracting cholesterol

    Make sure you have your “annual” check-up in the summer time

    / Dr Sandy
  • sending your kid to bootcamp won't stop childhood obesity

    Moving more won’t stop your kid from getting fat

    / Dr Sandy
  • cholesterol at the scene of the accident

    Bone cells are stiffening up your arteries not cholesterol

    / Dr Sandy
  • brain size the problem in ADHD

    Are kids with ADHD just acting according to their brain age

    / Dr Sandy
  • plastering the blood vessel with calcium

    Calcium supplements are building bones and breaking hearts

    / Dr Sandy
  • fat cell groom trying to pull triglyceride bride over the threshold

    Go on a diet even if you think you have nothing to lose

    / Dr Sandy
  • img-47

    The vitamin B12 heist that happens when you take metformin

    / Dr Sandy
  • hepcidin waving his calculator with cell city and ferriportin pump in the background

    Iron loaded macrophages

    / Dr Sandy
  • img-49

    Unlocking the Hidden Dangers of Iron Supplements

    / Dr Sandy
  • baby bottle sitting in a sea of tiny plastic particles

    Guarding Your Baby’s Gut: The Alarming Reality of Microplastics in Bottles

    / Dr Sandy

RSS Recent posts

Dr Sandy Dr Sandy Evans, PhD

Located in Johannesburg, South Africa

Disclaimer : The stories and articles are provided as a service. Dr Sandy's opinions are for information only, and are not intended to diagnose or prescribe. For your specific diagnosis and treatment, consult your doctor or health care provider.
 

Book an appointment

Calendar icon
 

Connect with Dr Sandy

facebook 40
you tube 40
pinterest 40
linkedin 40
 

Categories

Featured posts

  • asprosin the sugar plum fairy

    Why sugar levels are high despite NOT eating

    22149 views / Posted
  • poop getting stuck

    The fix for constipation is to go on a low fibre diet

    21278 views / Posted
  • oatmeal breakfast being beaten by egg

    Which is a better breakfast, egg or oatmeal ?

    19778 views / Posted
 

©2011-2023 Spoonful of Science

Menu

  • Meet Dr Sandy
  • Disclosure/disclaimer
  • Privacy policy
  • Comment policy
  • Contact
Tweet
Share
Pin
Share