Browse: Home / Obesity / The danger of “finish your broccoli or else”

Menu

Skip to content
  • About
  • Better Body Chemistry School
  • Book a health conversation
  • Speaking query
  • The “Big” Spoons
Header image

BBC

Small things can make a big difference to your health

advertisement

Menu

Skip to content
  • Home
  • Free Resources
    • 31 days to Better Body Chemistry
    • Willpower Report
    • Weight loss e-course
    • Better Body Chemistry for Expecting Moms
    • The ups and downs of insulin resistance
    • Candy Floss Boards
    • Weight tracker
  • Library
  • Shop
  • Lucky dip
  • Sound bites
  • Buy me a coffee
  • Contact

The danger of “finish your broccoli or else”

Posted by Dr Sandy on in Obesity | 556 Views | Leave a response
WhatsApp
Reddit
Share
More
Tweet
Pin
Share

Share Button

Click to listen to the audio…

The danger of “finish your broccoli or else”

Clean your plate talk probably doesn’t turn your child into a vegetable lover, instead it turns them into a heffa lump.

Do you make a scene when food is left on the plate by your children ?

Fighting talk at the dinner table

I can remember the food fights that went on – eat your vegetables or NO TV.   The other tactic, which was employed regularly, was references to starving kids in Ethiopia.

Of course, no TV had some personal relevance, but I felt feathers for starving kids in far away places.

The threats didn’t curtail my TV habits much – I was a wilful child, enforcing rules was often more trouble than it was worth.

More vegetables – NOT

Don’t think the tough talk made much difference to my consumption of vegetables either.

“Healthy” foods were never high on my culinary agenda.  I loved SUGAR.

But a study suggests the “Clean  plate” talk, might have made a difference to my eating habits in the long run. The difference was not positive.

The dangers of clean plate living

The clean the plate mantra, seems to have a habit of back firing, according to research published by Cornell Food & Brand Lab.

Clean plate thinking dupes the neurons in charge of managing appetite.

Wiring the clean plater up, for a lifetime of cleaning plates, irrespective of hunger and saiety.

Pre-schoolers loading up their plates

The research team dished up the mid-morning snack, at a local daycare centre.  On the menu,  an all you want serving of Fruit loops.

63 children participated in the study.   The children were in charge of “filling” the bowl.  They needed to shout “WHEN,” when the bowl was full enough to fill their tummies.  Before being served their bowl of cereal, the researchers recorded how much cereal had been added by weighing the dish.

The B part of the study, involved finding out a little bit about the “Clean Plate” philosophies and practices of the children’s families.

Clean plate club members  plated up

Logic would suggest – a clean plate child would err on the side of too little, to avoid the stress of being forced to finish a bowl full of stuff they may not necessarily want.

But, somewhat surprisingly, members of the “Clean Plate Club” tended to do the opposite…

they stacked up their plates with MORE.

Could the off switch already be on the blink ?

The I am full message

In principle at least, we really should not overeat because there are lots of systems tasked with getting the “I am FULL” message, from the stomach to the brain.

But we do overeat.

The  consequence …………………obesity.

I AM FULL

When your child turns up his/her nose at the broccoli – they probably are full, having satisfied their energy requirements on the more desirable items on the plate.  Forcing the broccoli issue seems like the right thing to do,  because the broccoli has a bunch of phytonutrients which were not in the noodles or stew.

But eating those few extra spoons of broccoli, ends up undermining the I AM FULL message.

FULL is relative

The stomach finds room for the extra food, so the stomach learns the I AM FULL message,  is not an absolute – there is wiggle room.

The wiggle room is the difference between eating what you need and OVEREATING.

At the same time, the  brain learns something.

Full has wiggle room i.e. when I feel full, I’m not really full full.

Which sets you up to indulge on a regular basis.  Oh dear !

Broccoli is not so nice

Broccoli is going to be left to the end of a meal – it really doesn’t taste too good.   So when you dish up dinner, don’t overdo it, rather serve a little less food and be sure there is enough room for the broccoli too.

You don’t want to inadvertently overfeed the developing brain, when it is learning the rules.

Don’t overfeed

Help your child’s brain learn what full is.

Watch how you enforce those “CLEAN PLATE” rules.

Clean plating will not turn your child into a vegetable lover, but it might make your child obese.

Share Button
Consequences of Belonging to the “Clean Plate Club”. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine (2008)  162 (10): 994.  B. Wansink, C. Payne  and C. Werle. 

Further reading

serve dessert with dinnerDessert should be part of your child’s dinner

There is ALWAYS room for dessert. ALWAYS. Dessert is eaten, because it tastes good, not because of hunger. By serving dessert with dinner – hunger rules.

working mom serving dinner laterWhy being a working Mom puts your child at risk of childhood obesity

It’s got nothing to do with dietary habits, meal time routines, frequency of family meals, time spent watching TV or physical activity, the problem is….

feeding baby spoons of pureeA spoonful of puree makes the baby grow round

The aim of the game, to feed your toothless wonder, mushed up food on a spoon. Spooning it in – ensures your little one grows up BIG, real BIG.

Want to discover more ways to create BETTER BODY CHEMISTRY ?

WhatsApp
Reddit
Share
More
Tweet
Pin
Share
Posted in Obesity | Tagged appetite, brain, broccoli, clean plate club, hunger, I am full, neurons, obesity, overeat, phytonutrients, saiety, snack, stomach, stress, sugar, vegetables

Sugar gremlins are REAL

Connect with us

facebook you tube pinterest 40 google plus 40 Linkedin

willpower report
  • Popular
  • Featured
  • Recent
  • asprosin the sugar plum fairy

    Why sugar levels are high despite NOT eating

    19386 views / Posted
  • poop getting stuck

    The fix for constipation is to go on a low fibre diet

    19071 views / Posted
  • oatmeal breakfast being beaten by egg

    Which is a better breakfast, egg or oatmeal ?

    18755 views / Posted
  • chewing gum relieving postoperative ileus

    A stick of chewing gum gets the gut going after surgery

    16604 views / Posted
  • carbonated water bubbles fill you up

    Fizzing up the water flattens your appetite

    15364 views / Posted
  • sun extracting cholesterol

    Make sure you have your “annual” check-up in the summer time

    / Dr Sandy
  • sending your kid to bootcamp won't stop childhood obesity

    Moving more won’t stop your kid from getting fat

    / Dr Sandy
  • cholesterol at the scene of the accident

    Bone cells are stiffening up your arteries not cholesterol

    / Dr Sandy
  • brain size the problem in ADHD

    Are kids with ADHD just acting according to their brain age

    / Dr Sandy
  • plastering the blood vessel with calcium

    Calcium supplements are building bones and breaking hearts

    / Dr Sandy
  • corona virus sporting his beautiful crown

    How to overcome long covid sooner rather than later

    / Dr Sandy
  • the metabolic big 5 of health

    The big 5 of health is an out dated concept

    / Dr Sandy
  • cholesterol scratching a unwell heart

    A cholesterol level in the normal range won’t guarantee no heart troubles

    / Dr Sandy
  • Missing image

    Metabolically healthy obese are not doomed

    / Dr Sandy
  • brain being drained of energy by a cell phone

    Chatting on your mobile phone might be making you fat !

    / Dr Sandy

RSS Recent posts

Dr Sandy Dr Sandy Evans, PhD

Located in Johannesburg, South Africa

Book an appointment with Spoonful of Science using SetMore
Disclaimer : The stories and articles are provided as a service. Dr Sandy's opinions are for information only, and are not intended to diagnose or prescribe. For your specific diagnosis and treatment, consult your doctor or health care provider.
 
 

Connect with Dr Sandy

facebook 40
you tube 40
pinterest 40
google plus 40
linkedin 40
meetup 40
 

Categories

Featured posts

  • asprosin the sugar plum fairy

    Why sugar levels are high despite NOT eating

    19386 views / Posted
  • poop getting stuck

    The fix for constipation is to go on a low fibre diet

    19071 views / Posted
  • oatmeal breakfast being beaten by egg

    Which is a better breakfast, egg or oatmeal ?

    18755 views / Posted
 

©2011-2022 Spoonful of Science

Menu

  • Meet Dr Sandy
  • Disclosure/disclaimer
  • Privacy policy
  • Comment policy
  • Contact
Redirect Stakk
Thank You

Beat your SUGAR CRAVINGS, using biology, NOT psychology

Download our FREE REPORT entitled, "How to get the Willpower you Need to Trump Sugar's Power"

  • Do you have a sugar gremlin ?
  • Discover the biology behind sugar gremlins
  • Learn about the 10 weapons you can use to TAME YOUR SUGAR GREMLIN

Get instant access

WhatsApp
Reddit
Share
More
Tweet